Book review – The Stasi Poetry Circle, by Philip Oltermann

Title: The Stasi Poetry Circle: The Creative Writing Class That Tried to Win the Cold War

Author: Philip Oltermann

Publisher: Faber & Faber, 2022

Reviewed by: Rhonda Cotsell, Ballarat Writers Inc. Book Review Group

The Stasi Poetry Circle is a fascinating work combining poetry and politics and confirming the important role poetry, reading and writing holds in any society on multiple levels personal and communal. Important and satisfying as an individual activity and as a tool to express both radical and law abiding principles.

The author, Philip Oltermannn, is a German-born British journalist and Chief of the Guardian’s Berlin Bureau since 2016. He has also written How to Write and Keeping Up with the Germans: A History of Anglo-German Encounters.

The story of how, where and why the Poetry Circle came to be is also a glimpse into the beginnings of what followed postwar WW2 Germany; fascinating insights into the thinking behind it, and especially the relationship between the power of literature, and the imperative of work.

A true story, it is an easy read including an extensive list of sources in both English and German and a useful index. The contents list is cleverly constructed of different poetry forms matching political content held within each chapter. Throughout the work Poetry Circle activities, and poetry itself, interweave neatly with historical and political detail.

The poetry circle idea was one outcome of a calculated decision with a higher purpose in mind. As the GRD worked not only to repair its shattered infrastructure, it also sought to reshape the lives of those who survived, creating a new East German society along strictly along Marxist lines.  

Its beginnings were born from the dream of one man, Johannes Becher, whose aim was for a Post War East Berlin to rise from the ashes to be a city of Literaturhesellschaft or ‘literature society’ made up only of ‘workers who wrote and writers who worked’.

The aim of this group: to learn lyrical verse.

Two-hour meetings were held once a month. Poems were to be written outside work hours and to be read aloud by all members, the leaders’ criticism shaped by kindness, and to educate. Officers could wear casual clothes, the young soldiers not. There were hiccups. The young soldiers first poems were all about love, this blamed on a previous leader who had also encouraged poetry written that made readers laugh. The Circle’s new leader had to work hard to lead this class to writing poems in the right direction, i.e., to ‘think Russia’, by celebrating the drama of the Revolution and encourage political debate, because

Poetry … was ‘the very definition of everything good and beautiful, of a more meaningful humane way of living’: it was ‘a creative order, an elevated form of existence’, the ‘eternal transcendence of man’.

Creating this new society founded on literature also included a plan to increase the number of East Germans reading, as part of their daily routines, from 37 per cent to 85-90 per cent. In 1973 it was decreed that larger factories have on-site libraries with collections numbering 500-5000 books and a part time librarian, if larger, a full-time librarian. These and other actions resulted not only in increased reading but also increased understanding of text, or reading between the lines, whether poetry or newspaper article.

Furthermore, during the famine years immediately following the end of the war, artists and actors received larger care food parcels and exiled writers returning home received higher access to building materials to rebuild their homes. Along with key workers like roofers, miners and bricklayers, leading artists and scientists received, among other privileges, income tax cuts and generous retirement pay.

Philip Oltermann talks about The Stasi Poetry Circle

@ Late Night Live on ABC Radio

The Stasi poetry circle, and those already in existence as a result of the dreams of Literaturhesellschaft, followed a set pattern: worker and writer not to be separate, no longer writers locked in ‘bourgeois writing dens’ separate from the ‘manual workers in factories and coal mines’. Workers and writers coming home at the end of their working days to write poetry. Particularly sonnets.

Sonnets because Becher believed that creative writing would not only reflect social conditions, but also shape them. Becher believed the structure of a sonnet mirrored the Marxist view of historical progress – as voiced by the German philosopher Hegel, that

… history moves towards a higher stage of freedom in a ‘dialectical’ … that it follows the same non-linear three-step pattern as an argument: from an idea, the thesis, to a contradiction of that idea, the antithesis, to a solution that resolves the tension between the two ideas

But turning it around such that progress would occur led not by ideas but by material realities.

Predictably it also meant keeping an eye on what its poets were doing. In every group, in the role of learner or already published poet, was a spy. That person was also a member of another group called the Working Circle of Writing Checkists, an exclusive group made up of all the spies participating within but also reporting on the words and perceived attitudes of their unknowing fellow students.

The Cheka … the abbreviated nickname of the Soviet Union’s secret police, … on which East Germany had modelled its own state security organ … better known as the Stasi.

Ultimately Becher’s vision that politics would respect culture as an equal,  in his own words as ‘a great sovereign power’ ultimately failed, appropriated by self-serving politics for its own ends.

Still, although the term ‘literature society’ never made it into official legislation it had significant impact at the rock face of rebuilding of East Berlin, and

‘… it would rattle around politicians’ heads for the next four decades: in 1981 General Secretary Erich Honecker still championed his state as a ‘country of readers’ – as opposed to what he called the ‘bestseller country’ on the other side of the Berlin Wall.

Reading this book made me think, which is what any good book does. Because of it I like to think Becher’s dream did not fail on all levels. Though not stated directly, as a reader I felt that what Becher planned and got done must have played a significant role in lifting the lives of the war exhausted population left behind surrounded by the ruins of their lives and their homes. By appealing to their minds, and to what everything else literature gives us all – internal tools to start again. Books and librarians in factories and support for the creators, the encouragement of the arts and freedom, teaching people to write poetry, could not have failed to make any impact at all.

And though the book strikes those of us on the opposite side of the political spectrum as somewhat strange and funny, learning to to read between the lines as Becher dreamt for all readers, suggests a lot more about where work and creativity intersect.

In Conversation with Kerri Rogan

November 4th at Ballaarat Mechanics’ Institute 6:30 pm- 8:00 pm

$11.00

Humffray Room

Get Tickets

Kerri Rogan author event promoting Witchy Sister book

Some homes never forget the people they belong to. After the death of her mother and the breakdown of her marriage, Kate Laird wants nothing more than a fresh start. The last thing she wants is to reconnect with the family legacy she spent years trying to escape.

But when she is drawn to Twisted Willow – the ancestral cottage of generations of witches – strange things begin to happen. Ancestors whisper in her dreams. Magic stirs in the walls. And a widowed father named David awakens feelings she thought she’d buried long ago.

As the cottage calls her deeper into its secrets, Kate must make a choice: continue running from who she is or finally embrace the witch within.

Book cover of Witchy Sister by Kerri Rogan

About the author

Kerri Rogan, author

Kerri was the child in English class who always received the following note from her teacher – ‘Great story, Kerri, if but a little too long’.

Now she lets the characters dictate how long the story is and lives in constant awe and wonder at producing something out of thin air. The imagination is a wonderous thing. She lives in the country where she can see the sun rise and set, be dazzled by the vastness of the sky, and the wonder of the stars, planets and meteorites.

Kerri shares this space with her husband and many rescued animals.

$11 per person includes gst, plus booking feem also includes light refreshment. All proceeds go to the Ballaarat Mechanics’ Institute to support the staging of our author events.


Book on-line or contact Rosemary at the Libary via email library@ballaratmi.org.au or phone (03) 5331 3042

Get Tickets

This event takes place on Wadawurrung Country. Ballaarat Mechanics’ Institute acknowledges the Wadawurrung People of the Kulin Nation as the first inhabitants and Traditional Custodians of the lands where we work, learn and create. Always Was, Always Will Be, Aboriginal Land.

Book review – The Boy Who Loved Dolls, by John A. Scott

Title: The Boy Who Loved Dolls

Author: John A. Scott

Publisher: Puncher & Wattman; RRP: $34.95

Reviewed by: Jason Nahrung, Ballarat Writers Inc. Book Review Group

The premise feels familiar: a fan/tyro/researcher gets a rare and unexpected opportunity to spend time with/interview/work with their hero. The location is remote, communications unreliable. The hero is not what they seem. Secrets are revealed. Bad things happen.

In this instance, our protagonist, documentary filmmaker and movie reviewer Susan Vaughan, has sufficient mileage and enough nous to raise the attention of the subject of her filmic interest, reclusive French director Jean-Jacques Baille. An invitation is made for her to interview him at his secluded manor outside Melbourne. It’s 1987: the interview will be preserved on video tape.

Often such scenarios pit subject and interviewer, an air of menace building as the layers are peeled back. John A. Scott, a poet and novelist with 18 books under his belt and two Miles Franklin shortlistings among an impressive array of kudos, breaks the pattern. We are exposed to a teasing chain of tests as the director puts Susan through her paces in not so much a game of survival, but of trust.

In the background (and prologue) is the kidnapping of Baille’s Australian wife, Anna, never to be heard from or of again. And following on from that crucial event, the director’s last movie, Christophe, le Peintre (the Painter), a change of artistic direction that has particularly captured Susan’s attention.

There are distractions: the lookalike actor from Christophe, the son with a talent for making mandolins, Susan’s fraught background with mother and sister key players.

There are intrigues: the room paying tribute to Anna. Baille’s fascination with dolls and resultant collection. The director’s childhood in war-torn France, his great love for Australian wife Anna, the mystery of her abduction.

And there are, of course, revelations: the mysterious pasts of both interviewer and subject unable to be confined, their psychologies laid bare.

Read more about The Boy Who Loved Dolls

@ Australian Arts Review

Scott has excelled in creating Baille’s oeuvre, with specific scenes – the acknowledgements gives a nod to real-life inspirations as well as the roots of some of Baille’s attitudes towards other directors – realistically drawn and some (but ah, which?) revelatory in retrospect.

The story itself is told (overtly so, though beautifully) at a leisurely pace, as befits a series of interviews, and something of a remove, which reflects the documentary nature of the narrative but risks disengagement. The story is broken into chronological parts in which chapters flow day by day, further broken into scenes, interspersed with the occasional letter and several transcripts of interview. Dialogue is the medium of plot, lies and truths offered for the sifting on the way to the almost inevitable climax that appears well before the end of the book. This triggers the after effect, essentially a dream sequence I found skimmable, followed by revelation by way of confession, and finally the quite effective epilogue.

Scott has constructed his documentary skilfully, clues, deceptions and misdirections seeded amidst the interactions, but it is not a style that invites the reader in, rather leaving them feeling like an eavesdropper, everything told, little left to imagine.  

As conversations go, it certainly has its points of interest, but for this viewer/reader it proved to be a little too orchestrated and esoteric to hold full attention for the duration.

Review copy supplied

Book review – Songs That Changed the World, by Andrew Clarke

Title: Songs that Changed the World: Music of Resistance and Transformation

Author: Andrew Clarke

Publisher: Gelding Street Press; RRP: $39.99

Reviewed by: Jason Nahrung, Ballarat Writers Inc. Book Review Group

There are 42 songs in this collection, the number apparently a nod to Douglas Adams’ famed meaning of life, and appropriately so: as the author notes, these tunes have impacted lives and taken on lives of their own.

 Melbourne-based Andrew Clarke, who has written more than 30 books, with this his third for Gelding Street Press, whittled his selection from a hundred, looking for songs that ‘shifted thinking, sparked action, or gave people a voice they didn’t know they had’.

The list starts with ‘Strange Fruit’, by Billie Holiday (1939), and ends with Sooking’s ‘La Liberte’, an Algerian/French protest song from 2019. A variety of musical styles and political and social movements are included. ‘Y.M.C.A.’ – gay pride, with a sly wink to those who didn’t quite get it, and later, Lady Gaga’s ‘Born This Way’, ‘a personal anthem so many in the LGBTQ+ community could relate to’. Helen Reddy and Loretta Lynn, stepping up for feminism; Joni Mtchell for environmentalism. Johnny Cash, Clarke argues, kicked open Nashville’s door to let politics into country music.

To his credit, Clarke has reached further than the obvious must-have American offerings (Pete Seeger, Sam Cooke, Bob Dylan) to highlight songs from Rwanda, Italy, Japan and more that have become the themes of popular movements.

As any magazine editor knows, a list is good fodder for a chinwag, not for just what’s in but what’s out. I won’t buy into that, but Clarke has left room for some watercooler discussion by spreading the idea of impactful songs beyond that of blatant protest. He labels ‘Panama’ by Van Halen the most unusual inclusion, an example of music used as ‘psychological torture, a sharp contrast to its traditional role as a unifying cultural force’.

He notes how Bruce Springsteen’s ‘Born in the USA’ and Creedence Clearwater Revival’s ‘Fortunate Son’ have been co-opted by politics that clearly haven’t paid attention to the lyrics, how the localised subject of songs such as Midnight Oil’s ‘Beds Are Burning’ can find fresh meaning elsewhere where the struggle remains the same.

Nena gets a (red) balloon for Cold War angst (with an interesting comparison of the original German versus the English version), the Beatles and Elvis win spots by popular vote, Band Aid for global achievement. There’s the occasional double dip, notably comparing the approach/synergy of headliner U2’s ‘Sunday Bloody Sunday’ with the Cranberries’ ‘Zombie’ 11 years later (similarly responding to an outrage in Northern Ireland).

A strength is the background to the music: perhaps something of their genesis, how they ruffled feathers, shook up the industry (Triple J earns a mention for its championing of N.W.A. when no other radio station would), became inspirational even if by accident.

The book itself is a glossy production making the most of its record motif, Clarke’s text beefed up with images of the artists and acts of protest. Which is where a couple of reservations put a scratch in the vinyl.

While the images have their sources acknowledged, it wouldn’t have hurt to have a few captions rather than trust to common knowledge or intuitive leap based on the names dropped in the text. Why is Cash pictured with Ray Charles? Is that Joan Baez giving Seeger’s ‘We Shall Overcome’ fresh air in a live performance?

Hear all about Songs that Changed the World

@ Channel 9’s Extra

The text also seems to get caught in a groove at times – the Beatles’ wit, charm and style are remarked upon twice on the same page, and twice we are told ‘Born in the USA’ was a Trojan horse – and sometimes the information feels like duplication: in the case of the comparison of the Sex Pistols to Nirvana (explosion/fallout, fuse/flare), quite literally.

That interplay of the songs, when done with restraint, is another strength, with Clarke noting how musicians respond to and build on those who have gone before: ‘Respect’ (Aretha Franklin) to ‘Love Child’ (Diana Ross & the Supremes) to ‘I Am Woman’ (Reddy).

Clarke has reached out to cover a variety of nations and genres to provide a list where Marvin Gaye and Bob Marley rub shoulders with Public Enemy and Green Day, providing a useful primer as well as a conversation starter.

‘Sometimes,’ Clarke writes, ‘we don’t know what we need until someone puts it in lyrics.’ And that, as events in the United States continue to demonstrate, won’t change any time soon.

Review copy provided

Upcoming Members Workshops

Keira Lockyer Presents:

TACKLING RESEARCH TODAY … FROM SNAIL MAIL TO AI.
Whatever you are writing or plan to write, and whether it is about real or imaginary people or places, research is essential. Everything changes so quickly these days that no matter what time or century your piece is about, and how much you know, you will still need to do some checking.
At our 26th October meeting, member Keira Lockyer will share some of her research adventures over the last 28 years. These include two years investigating over 400 Jewish pioneers who came to Ballarat during the gold rush for her prizewinning 2024 book, and her research on the Anzacs and the 1915 Lone Pine conflict for the 2015 Gallipoli centenary.
Her current research projects include helping people discover the stories of their ancestors through DNA and research. This has led her to look at London’s Flash houses and brothels during the Regency days, the Japanese pearlers of the Tiwi Islands, and their POW camps in Singapore, and Abe Saffron and his Sydney underworld of the 1960s. Besides advising what current free research options are available, Keira will also provide a hard copy list of her favourite Victorian, Ballarat and worldwide sources.

A BOOK LAUNCH INVITATION

YOU ARE CORDIALLY INVITED TO JOIN US FOR THE LAUNCH OF:

TALL POPPY ON THE GOLDFIELDS

THE LIFE AND TIMES OF HENRY FOSTER

1819–1884

BY
BEVERLEY FOSTER

From the untamed frontier of the Western District in 1842, the Victorian goldfields and the dry and dusty Northern District of Victoria comes the remarkable story of a man who lived with courage, conviction and an unyielding strength of character.
Loved by thousands, he was reviled by a few men in high places who would bring him to his knees.

Join us to unveil the life and times of Henry Foster—early pioneer and an extraordinary figure of colonial Victoria. A story as yet untold.

SATURDAY, 24th OCTOBER 2026 from 1.30 pm – 4.30 pm

The Soldiers Lounge and Balcony
NORTH STAR HOTEL
302 Lydiard Street, Ballarat

An afternoon unveiling untold history, old stories made new and a celebration of Colonial Victoria. We would be greatly honoured by your presence. Ground floor lift is available.

RSVP would be appreciated at tallpoppy1842@gmail.com

Book review – Second Place, by Rachel Cusk

Title: Second Place

Author: Rachel Cusk

Publisher: Faber & Faber / Allen & Unwin, 2021; RRP: $39.99

Reviewed by: Frank Thompson, Ballarat Writers Inc. Book Review Group

The author

Rachel Cusk is a Canadian British writer. Her debut novel Saving Agnes (1993) received the Whitbread First Novel Award. Since then, she has produced a significant body of work, including at least nineteen novels and several nonfiction works. Second Place was longlisted for a Booker Prize and awarded second place (ironically) in the French Literary award Le Prix Femina Étrange in 2022.

Cusk studied English at New College Oxford and has been a professor of Creative Writing for Kingston University UK.

The book

This novel, a chance discovery in the library, was inspired by the 1932 memoir Lorenzo in Taos by Mabel Dodge Luanne covering the time D. H.  Lawrence came to stay with her in Taos, New Mexico. This is not the first novel by Cusk drawing inspiration from other literary works. The Country Life in 1997 drew inspiration from Stella Gibbons’ Cold Comfort Farm and Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre.

For Second Place Cusk employs a unique narrative style, bordering on epistolary. The protagonist M addresses a character named Jeffers. The intimacy feels like a letter. M begins by reminding Jeffers that she once told him that she had met the Devil.  She now reveals to Jeffers that earlier on that same day she experienced a personal epiphany when she came across a gallery exhibiting the work of the artist L. M was struggling with her identity, motherhood and quite possibly her sexuality.

I found the use of single capital letters for some characters a little awkward at times.

Having set the story’s context, Cusk moves the time frame forward some fifteen years. M is now married to Tony, she feels strongly connected with her husband and the marshland on which they live, but is looking to understand that connection. To resolve this, M decides to invite L to come and stay.

M and Tony lead lives of sustainable isolation. Their acreage borders an estuary and has significant natural beauty of an ethereal nature. They appear to live a kind of subsistence lifestyle supplemented by earnings from Tony’s fishing with the other villagers. Details are scarce.

Indeed, Cusk is oblique about several things including the timing for the story which appears to be towards the end of the pandemic. Also, the actual geographic setting is left unclear.

Rachel Cusk on her writing process

@ Louisiana Channel

The name Second Place comes from the building Tony and M find when clearing an overgrown area of their property. They fix it up with the intention of using it to accommodate guests – artists, writers and others, thus creating a second dwelling / place on the property.

The story line is relatively simple: M writes to L, inviting him to come and stay on the expectation he will find the surrounding landscape interesting enough to paint.

After initially accepting M’s invitation, he cancels in favour of spending time on an island. Finally, he agrees to come but his circumstances have changed greatly. He is down on his luck – the bottom has fallen out of the art market, and he is financially hard pressed. Eventually, he turns up with another woman in tow: Brett, a wealthy younger woman having a fling with an aging and fallen star of the art world.

The relationship between M and L is difficult, not hostile but strained. M is disappointed with L and his attitude to the Second Place.  

I could see parallels in L and Lawerence’s attitude towards their patrons. Perhaps this has something to do with the expectations people like M can have of an artist. On the surface L appears to be exploiting M’s hospitality. However, L was the one being exploited by both M and Brett, albeit for varied reasons. Perhaps, Brett and M were giving L something physical but in return they wanted part of his artistic soul. This is the basis for the story: the tension and the relationship between the artist and the viewer and/or patron.

Second Place is an intriguing story, and the character exploration is excellent. I enjoyed the way it was constructed and the way Cusk resolved the ending. It is a well-paced story with clever, readable writing. Well worth the trip to the library.

« Older posts

© 2026 Ballarat Writers

Theme by Anders Noren — Up ↑