Title: The Stasi Poetry Circle: The Creative Writing Class That Tried to Win the Cold War
Author: Philip Oltermann
Publisher: Faber & Faber, 2022
Reviewed by: Rhonda Cotsell, Ballarat Writers Inc. Book Review Group
The Stasi Poetry Circle is a fascinating work combining poetry and politics and confirming the important role poetry, reading and writing holds in any society on multiple levels personal and communal. Important and satisfying as an individual activity and as a tool to express both radical and law abiding principles.
The author, Philip Oltermannn, is a German-born British journalist and Chief of the Guardian’s Berlin Bureau since 2016. He has also written How to Write and Keeping Up with the Germans: A History of Anglo-German Encounters.
The story of how, where and why the Poetry Circle came to be is also a glimpse into the beginnings of what followed postwar WW2 Germany; fascinating insights into the thinking behind it, and especially the relationship between the power of literature, and the imperative of work.
A true story, it is an easy read including an extensive list of sources in both English and German and a useful index. The contents list is cleverly constructed of different poetry forms matching political content held within each chapter. Throughout the work Poetry Circle activities, and poetry itself, interweave neatly with historical and political detail.
The poetry circle idea was one outcome of a calculated decision with a higher purpose in mind. As the GRD worked not only to repair its shattered infrastructure, it also sought to reshape the lives of those who survived, creating a new East German society along strictly along Marxist lines.
Its beginnings were born from the dream of one man, Johannes Becher, whose aim was for a Post War East Berlin to rise from the ashes to be a city of Literaturhesellschaft or ‘literature society’ made up only of ‘workers who wrote and writers who worked’.
The aim of this group: to learn lyrical verse.
Two-hour meetings were held once a month. Poems were to be written outside work hours and to be read aloud by all members, the leaders’ criticism shaped by kindness, and to educate. Officers could wear casual clothes, the young soldiers not. There were hiccups. The young soldiers first poems were all about love, this blamed on a previous leader who had also encouraged poetry written that made readers laugh. The Circle’s new leader had to work hard to lead this class to writing poems in the right direction, i.e., to ‘think Russia’, by celebrating the drama of the Revolution and encourage political debate, because
Poetry … was ‘the very definition of everything good and beautiful, of a more meaningful humane way of living’: it was ‘a creative order, an elevated form of existence’, the ‘eternal transcendence of man’.
Creating this new society founded on literature also included a plan to increase the number of East Germans reading, as part of their daily routines, from 37 per cent to 85-90 per cent. In 1973 it was decreed that larger factories have on-site libraries with collections numbering 500-5000 books and a part time librarian, if larger, a full-time librarian. These and other actions resulted not only in increased reading but also increased understanding of text, or reading between the lines, whether poetry or newspaper article.
Furthermore, during the famine years immediately following the end of the war, artists and actors received larger care food parcels and exiled writers returning home received higher access to building materials to rebuild their homes. Along with key workers like roofers, miners and bricklayers, leading artists and scientists received, among other privileges, income tax cuts and generous retirement pay.
Philip Oltermann talks about The Stasi Poetry Circle
@ Late Night Live on ABC Radio
The Stasi poetry circle, and those already in existence as a result of the dreams of Literaturhesellschaft, followed a set pattern: worker and writer not to be separate, no longer writers locked in ‘bourgeois writing dens’ separate from the ‘manual workers in factories and coal mines’. Workers and writers coming home at the end of their working days to write poetry. Particularly sonnets.
Sonnets because Becher believed that creative writing would not only reflect social conditions, but also shape them. Becher believed the structure of a sonnet mirrored the Marxist view of historical progress – as voiced by the German philosopher Hegel, that
… history moves towards a higher stage of freedom in a ‘dialectical’ … that it follows the same non-linear three-step pattern as an argument: from an idea, the thesis, to a contradiction of that idea, the antithesis, to a solution that resolves the tension between the two ideas
But turning it around such that progress would occur led not by ideas but by material realities.
Predictably it also meant keeping an eye on what its poets were doing. In every group, in the role of learner or already published poet, was a spy. That person was also a member of another group called the Working Circle of Writing Checkists, an exclusive group made up of all the spies participating within but also reporting on the words and perceived attitudes of their unknowing fellow students.
The Cheka … the abbreviated nickname of the Soviet Union’s secret police, … on which East Germany had modelled its own state security organ … better known as the Stasi.
Ultimately Becher’s vision that politics would respect culture as an equal, in his own words as ‘a great sovereign power’ ultimately failed, appropriated by self-serving politics for its own ends.
Still, although the term ‘literature society’ never made it into official legislation it had significant impact at the rock face of rebuilding of East Berlin, and
‘… it would rattle around politicians’ heads for the next four decades: in 1981 General Secretary Erich Honecker still championed his state as a ‘country of readers’ – as opposed to what he called the ‘bestseller country’ on the other side of the Berlin Wall.
Reading this book made me think, which is what any good book does. Because of it I like to think Becher’s dream did not fail on all levels. Though not stated directly, as a reader I felt that what Becher planned and got done must have played a significant role in lifting the lives of the war exhausted population left behind surrounded by the ruins of their lives and their homes. By appealing to their minds, and to what everything else literature gives us all – internal tools to start again. Books and librarians in factories and support for the creators, the encouragement of the arts and freedom, teaching people to write poetry, could not have failed to make any impact at all.
And though the book strikes those of us on the opposite side of the political spectrum as somewhat strange and funny, learning to to read between the lines as Becher dreamt for all readers, suggests a lot more about where work and creativity intersect.